John Deere Vs Case IH Vs New Holland Tractors

We’ve pitted low hp John Deere tractors against Kubota, and Kubota against Mahindra. Now we’re stepping it up to mid-range hp tractors, including John Deere, Case IH and New Holland tractors.

To ensure an even playing field, we’ve picked the John Deere 5083E, Case IH Farmall JX90 and New Holland TD5050. All these tractors have similar engines, are all wheeled, have cabs and similar hp.

So let’s see how these tractors stack up.

The Walkaround: John Deere, Case IH & New Holland Tractors

To give you the best idea, we have found unbiased, clear and short clips that provide a 360-degree view of each of these tractors.

New Holland Tractor TD5050

Video via YouTube

New Holland say of their TD5 series, “They are intercooled, economical and reliable turbocharged engines, with a very efficient fuel consumption and long maintenance intervals of up to 600 hours, which will allow users to spend more time at work and less in the service workshop.”

John Deere Tractor 5083E

Video via YouTube

When it comes to the John Deere 5083E, Mr Brad Davis from Chesterfield Australia says it is the ultimate all-rounder tractor. “The 5083E is a strong, capable tractor built specifically for small farming applications. It has a tried-and-true tractor design, with an engine that will provide the buyer with years and years of solid service. It’s highly versatile and adaptable, perfect for smaller agricultural and hobby farm applications,” he said.

Case IH Tractor Farmall JX90

Video via YouTube

“One of the big features of the Farmall JX90 is the standard hydraulic Powershuttle as it provides better fuel efficiency and reduces operator fatigue in critical long working days,” says Mr Seamus McCarthy, Case IH Aus/NZ Product Manager, “Another benefit of the JX90 is that it is multi-purpose and its rear linkage lift capacity is over 3.5 tonne.”

Tractor Applications

So what do others in Australia and around the world use these tractors for? We did some digging and compiled a quick list of the most common uses for these particular tractors:

That’s not to say this is a finite list, but we found the above to be the most common applications used for these tractors.

In The Seat

Next, let’s take a look at some side-by-side comparisons when it comes to the cab and interior.

John Deere 5083E	Case IH Farmall JX90	New Holland TD5050
First impressions:
The cab feels very spacious. You have plenty of room to move and shift gears. And do it comfortably with the air suspension seat—a nice touch for operators spending hours and hours holed up in the cab. Visibility is great, especially with the bottom-drop window where you can easily see the attachments and PTO. Ergonomically designed, it’s easy for an operator to use this tractor effectively.	The slim roofline of the Farmall JX90 may be deceiving, but once you step inside the cab you feel how roomy this tractor really is.While it’s not a massive cab, there is plenty of headroom and doesn’t feel restrictive. The air-suspension seat provides great comfort for the operators, especially on those long days.It offers good visibility, thanks to the roof with high-visibility panel and slim pillars. Very easy to see loaders and attachments.	This tractor cab feels a little tighter fit than the other two, with the pedals much closer on the floor. You almost feel like your knees will hit the steering wheel. But once you shift yourself in the seat to accommodate, it’s not as noticeable. Otherwise, the levers and gears are easy to use. This also has good visibility thanks to the sloped hood and rear window.
Hits:
Air suspension seat Ergonomic design Easy to operate Power reverser transmission for easy switch from forward to reverse Foot throttle & standard clutch Rubber bedded floor Internal fuse box for easy access to change/check fuses Climate control & air conditioning	Air suspension seat with armrest Familiar layout Good value Ergonomic design Comes with some nice features Climate control & air conditioning Big comfortable cab Rubber bedded floor Adjustable steering column (up/down)	Suspension seat with high back and armrests Good value Ergonomic design Climate control & air conditioning Simple, easy-to-read dashboard Rubber bedded floor Interior toolbox comes standard
Misses:
A bit noisy in the cab The 3-point lever is a bit low	Levers have a mechanical feel Smaller cab but still feels roomy 4WD engagement is a lever instead of a button	A bit more noise in the cab than the JD A/C vents could be better placed Shift knob made from plastic, feels cheaper and has shorter life

Under The Bonnet

John Deere 5083E	Case IH Farmall JX90	New Holland TD5050
Hits:
Powerful Biggest fuel tank (134L) Fuel efficient Fuel tank under platform for ground-level fueling Lift capacity on the loader is good Robust drive line Tried-and-true transmission & engine	Powerful Easy no-tools service access Slide-out condenser for simple radiator cleanup Clean-burning & fuel efficient Higher lift capacity than competitors One-piece bonnet lifts nice and high Mesh screens help protect the radiator	Easy to service Heavy 3-point arms Excep?ional maneuverability Good fuel economy Capable of running 100% biodiesel from the factory Strong breakout force Heavier than competitors Higher lift capacity than JD Agile maneuverability Engine can produce up to 44% torque rise
Misses:
A bit light in the rear end No brake lock	PTO speed lever is located at the back of the tractor. This isn’t a big issue but worth mentioning	A little underpowered, forced to downshift Location of pro lever and remote handles could be better

Specs Breakdown

	John Deere 5083E	Case IH Farmall JX90	New Holland TD5050
Engine	John Deere PowerTech 4045 4.5L 4 cylinder	Iveco S8000 4-cylinder turbocharged	New Holland 4.5L 4-cylinder diesel
3-Point Hitch	Category 2	Category 2	Category 2
Lift Capacity (at ball ends)	2 100 kg	3 565 kg	2 279 kg
Gross HP	83	88	90
PTO HP	51	72	80
Transmission (standard)	12F/12R PowrReverser	12×12 Hydraulic Powershuttle	12F/12R with synchronised shuttle
Fuel Capacity	134 L	110L	90L
Weight (FWD)	3 350 kg	3 700 kg	3 780 kg
PTO Speed	540 RPM	540/1000 RPM	540 RPM
	More Specs	More Specs	More Specs

The Verdict

When it comes to enjoying a design built around the operator, the Case IH is a great option. Its ergonomic design makes those long days easier on the operator to reduce fatigue and improve productivity. The Case IH Farmall JX90 also comes standard with features that you find would be optional extras in other tractors.

If you’re looking for a heavy, strong and agile tractor, the New Holland tractor proves almost unbeatable value for money.

The John Deere is a good all-round tractor for smaller farming operations or hobby farms. It’s lighter in weight than the other two tractors, but has a robust drive line. The John Deere does boast the largest fuel tank by far—carrying up to 25 more litres per tank. This could make a huge impact out on the field, depending on the scale of your operation.

Did you find this article helpful? Let us know in the comments below. Or take a look at other tractors for sale.

Sources: Machines4U, TractorData, TractorBy Net.com, Deere.com.au/Chesterfield Australia representatives/John Deere 5E Series product brochures, CaseIH representatives/CaseIH Farmall Series Product Brochures, New Holland TD5000 Series Product Brochures